ST Alpha - "he could have stopped the criticism after the second one. the rest of this is just nitpicking and piling on" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 150

he could have stopped the criticism after the second one. the rest of this is just nitpicking and piling on

Posted by fatsquatch (aka chris) Jan 12 '10, 18:18

not that he's wrong about any of it but really the fundamental flaw is as he says in the first video. no clear protagonist. no strong antagonist. no conflict.

Responses:

i stopped before the end of the second one. -- nm - TFox Jan 12, 18:24
I just finished part 4. It occurred to me that the narrator could in so many ways be future Butthead of Beavis & Butthead. -- nm - HdnAgnda Jan 12, 18:21 10
- at a point it just becomes shooting fish in a barrell though -- nm - fatsquatch Jan 12, 18:23 9
  - But the shots he is taking are so funny. -- nm - HdnAgnda Jan 12, 18:25 5
    - and obvious -- nm - fatsquatch Jan 12, 18:34 4
      - where is your video? -- nm - Beaker Jan 12, 18:35 3
        
        oh...right. -- nm - Beaker Jan 12, 18:35 2
        
        buuuuuurn!!!! -- nm - nubby seacrest Jan 12, 18:41 1
        
        i don't deny the effort that went in to it. just, as i expected, about 60 minutes more than i ever want to think about Phantom Menace again in my - fatsquatch Jan 12, 18:56
  - [deleted] 2
    - you could take any film scene by scene and find flaws to mock - fatsquatch Jan 12, 18:29
    - the bit about the bet before the pod race was right on.... - Mel Profit Jan 12, 18:26

Post a message top

he could have stopped the criticism after the second one. the rest of this is just nitpicking and piling on

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.