ST Alpha - "this is what he said about taylor hicks, at audition time:" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 150

In response to "Hey Idolcylopedias. Has anyone won Idol that Simon voted no for in the tryouts? -- nm" by Redmond

this is what he said about taylor hicks, at audition time:

Posted by b! (aka starrynut) Jan 19 '10, 21:10

Simon�s Call: �My problem is, and I�ve always said this, it is not just about the voice. And you prove that.� He disagreed completely with Paula and Randy. He did not think Taylor could be commercially successful. Simon explained that Taylor should be singing backgrounds, �not in the spotlight.� He warned Taylor that although Paula and Randy were giving him a ticket to Hollywood, �they will not put you in the final group to be judged by public.� Ouch!

Responses:

"He did not think Taylor could be commercially successful" Doesn't he turn out to be right in the end? -- nm - Redmond Jan 19, 21:16 1
- yes, as far as records, after the start; but he ended up making a decent musical actor career for himself. - b! Jan 19, 21:18
he also wasn't fully positive about some others, but you'd have to dig deeper to see how he voted. nm but: -- (link) - b! Jan 19, 21:12 1
- Cool thanks all -- nm - Redmond Jan 19, 21:15

Post a message top

this is what he said about taylor hicks, at audition time:

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.