ST Alpha - "so if not pattinson, who? who's gorgeous enough to play edward? age notwithstanding; let's make it that easy." (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 162

so if not pattinson, who? who's gorgeous enough to play edward? age notwithstanding; let's make it that easy.

Posted by pilgrims and indians love mandy lane (aka amanda) Nov 21 '08, 08:55

is it james franco? ryan reynolds? who?

Responses:

Cillian Murphy -- nm - Amy Nov 21, 09:23
Henry Cavill -- nm - Dano Nov 21, 09:15
Even I think Pattinson is hot - con_carne Nov 21, 09:11
[deleted]
I know I am not horribly original here but OBLOO would have been perfect, Chance is the youngest - Pippy Nov 21, 09:06
Pattinson's nice to look at but needs help in the hair dept. -- nm - lileve Nov 21, 09:01
Tom Cruise! -- nm - Mop Nov 21, 08:59
Freddie Prinz Jr. -- nm - CQ with a gravy boat Nov 21, 08:58
too, is there not something to the fact that *bella's* understanding of edward's hotness is more important than is ours? -- nm - pilgrims and indians love mandy lane Nov 21, 08:58 4
- due to the books - it was a fact that everyone thought so as well - so they need to have it universal - Pippy Nov 21, 09:07
- That works for books and in real life. You can't put Danny DeVito up there and say "In Bella's eyes..." -- nm - Max Nov 21, 09:05 2
  - someone believeably attractive and charismatic like mad would work, is all I'm saying. chemistry matters. -- nm - pilgrims and indians love mandy lane Nov 21, 09:07 1
    - for Juno. Michael Cera as "hot vampire" would just be wrong. -- nm - Max Nov 21, 09:22
I don't think gorgeous matters since the guy they did cast is an ugmo. Just not ugly is a step up. -- nm - Ninja Cat Nov 21, 08:56
OBLOO -- nm - budice Nov 21, 08:55
I reiterate my strong Chace Crawford stance. -- nm - Callisto Nov 21, 08:55 4
- Is this the dude from Gossip Girl? My wife suggested some guy from that show. -- nm - JaxSean Nov 21, 09:03 2
  - yes - I think it does call for what they tried to get: an emo, hawt but tortured kind of look -- nm - Pippy Nov 21, 09:08
  - he is from Gossip Girl, yes. He's the prettiest one (though the worst actor). -- nm - Callisto Nov 21, 09:07
- yeah, that's not bad either. -- nm - pilgrims and indians love mandy lane Nov 21, 08:56

Post a message top

so if not pattinson, who? who's gorgeous enough to play edward? age notwithstanding; let's make it that easy.

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.