ST Alpha - "oh, then, for Dignan only" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 151

In response to "I've read the book, so I suspect I might know what you're talking about. nm" by Dignan

oh, then, for Dignan only

Posted by Andie (aka Andie) Feb 16 '10, 19:14

the first half is really gothic and seems overdone (like the opening music), but, then, it redeems itself.

Responses:

oh, but i don't think everyone will love it, fyi. -- nm - Andie Feb 16, 19:16 17
- which ones of us won't like it? split us into factions. -- nm - TFox Feb 16, 19:19 16
  - the people who like Tombstone will give it a B. The people who like The Ring will give it a C. The people who like The Others will give it a B+. - Andie Feb 16, 19:22 15
    - What about the people (read: person) who like(s) Blades of Glory? nm - Dignan Feb 16, 19:24 7
      - Your madness knows no boundaries. -- nm - David Feb 16, 19:41
      - Irrelevant. They won't pay to see this. -- nm - Andie Feb 16, 19:25 5
        
        Not true, I liked it and I will be seeing Shutter Island this weekend -- nm - J Feb 16, 19:32
        
        What about if Tom Cruise wanted to go on a man-date with The Rock? Would they enjoy it? nm - ralph wiggum Feb 16, 19:31 3
        
        Oh, they'd enjoy...something. nm - Dignan Feb 16, 19:36 1
        
        They'd enjoy comparing their indentical careers. -- nm - Inigo Feb 16, 20:13
        
        with Leo and Mark? yes, yes they would. -- nm - Andie Feb 16, 19:33
    - Awesome. I'm on Team Others. -- nm - TFox Feb 16, 19:23 5
      - I thought he was going to be the next great director, but he largely vanished. -- nm - David Feb 16, 19:43 3
        
        There is something very impressive about a guy who writes, directs, and *scores* his own movie. -- nm - TFox Feb 16, 19:46 2
        
        IIRC he has done it *every* time. -- nm - David Feb 16, 19:47 1
        
        imdb suggests maybe not for his 2009 release, but every one prior. -- nm - TFox Feb 16, 19:48
      - (that awesome was directed at you. this is a genius system and you have earned a day full of happiness tomorrow.) -- nm - TFox Feb 16, 19:23
    - I knew I wanted to see it! -- nm - CQ Feb 16, 19:22

Post a message top

oh, then, for Dignan only

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.