ST Alpha - "okay I see your points - so then why didn't they" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 151

In response to "secondly, the best one for him is no longer with us -- nm" by crash davis

okay I see your points - so then why didn't they

Posted by Epiphany (aka Epiphany) May 14 '10, 09:41

bring all the people back if Castiel came back? He could brought Jo back. She would be my 1st choice

Responses:

I would much prefer - loosilu May 14, 09:47 14
- How old do you think she was? - the wrong element, bad guy May 14, 09:57 7
  - Generally, I thought she was 8-10 years younger. -- nm - Will Hunting May 14, 10:05 2
    - I think it was less than that. - the wrong element, bad guy May 14, 10:11 1
      - I never tried to come up with numbers. she just seemed "young" to me. -- nm - loosilu May 14, 10:12
  - she seemed younger, like 19. -- nm - loosilu May 14, 09:58 3
    - I think she was supposed to be a little older than that. - the wrong element, bad guy May 14, 10:05 2
      - maybe so. But at the beginning she was portrayed as a much younger little sister. -- nm - loosilu May 14, 10:06 1
        
        Not intentionally. - the wrong element, bad guy May 14, 10:16
- see I think that would have been harder for the writers - Epiphany May 14, 09:50 3
  - ok, fair enough. In that case my first choice is - loosilu May 14, 09:51 2
    - they were hawt couple for sure -- nm - Epiphany May 14, 09:52 1
      - heh - the only two Deanbos on wikipedia with their own full length pages are Jo Harvelle and Bela Talbot -- nm - crash davis May 14, 10:10
- I forget what they say in the series, but in rl, she is only five years younger than him :) -- nm - crash davis May 14, 09:50 1
  - I liked how Jeffrey Dean Morgan was not old enough to be their father - hee. -- nm - Epiphany May 14, 09:52
I thought about this, but I think Buffy the Vampire Slayer covered this point really well one season - crash davis May 14, 09:43 5
- I can see your point - and she was with her mom -- nm - Epiphany May 14, 09:44 4
  - yeah - she was my favorite of all of them. and then Bella, in the sense I'd do bad things to her -- nm - crash davis May 14, 09:49 3
    - Bella was the prettiest - looked like a CoverGirl model -- nm - Epiphany May 14, 09:51 2
      - she was really fun too. -- nm - loosilu May 14, 09:52 1
        
        indeed -- nm - crash davis May 14, 09:52

Post a message top

okay I see your points - so then why didn't they

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.