ST Alpha - "David, I have much less problem with (spoilers)" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 163

David, I have much less problem with (spoilers)

Posted by musubi May 24 '10, 09:38

Jack leaving his imaginary purgatory son, than Jin and Sun leaving their daughter behind to be orphaned. I *hated* that.

I can accept Jack leaving Jack Jr, because he had the revelation that it wasn't "real".

Show Spoilers

Responses:

that was the one serious misstep recently that I hated as well. -- nm - Mel Profit May 24, 09:41
heh. When that happened - Reagen May 24, 09:40 30
- Hmm, I had no problem with it. - Nightcrawler May 24, 09:43 26
  - This doesn't wash for me. (spoils) - musubi May 24, 09:46 10
    - It bugged me, too. -- nm - Callisto May 24, 09:53
    - I hated it too. -- nm - loosilu May 24, 09:49
    - yep, it is that simple. (spoils) - Jovian May 24, 09:48 1
      - oops meant to go below spawns post -- nm - Jovian May 24, 09:49
    - This is really quite simple. - Nightcrawler May 24, 09:47 5
      - It was (spoils) - musubi May 24, 09:51 4
        
        I think they knew that, too - Reagen May 24, 09:55 1
        
        Exactly. Hell (spoils) - musubi May 24, 10:02
        
        i dont see how it negated anything. - tRuMaN May 24, 09:55 1
        
        Like I said, it negated all the character development (spoils) - musubi May 24, 10:15
  - spoiler - znufrii May 24, 09:44 14
    - I don't buy that. This is supposed to be (spoils) - musubi May 24, 09:48 11
      - it's an arguable point. - znufrii May 24, 09:53 10
        
        Look at their story arcs, it's all about (spoil) - musubi May 24, 09:57 8
        
        Yeah, they wrote that for the romantic ideal instead of emotional reality. (spoils) - Inigo May 24, 10:02 6
        
        yes he was. -- nm - loosilu May 24, 10:03
        
        yes to your IM. (spoilers) - znufrii May 24, 10:02 4
        
        oh, that was another thing that bugged me - Reagen May 24, 10:05 3
        
        Yeah, especially since he was older in the normal timeline. (spoils) - Inigo May 24, 10:11 2
        
        I think they really wanted to give us what you said in your IM, - loosilu May 24, 10:13
        
        (spoilers) - znufrii May 24, 10:13
        
        I totally agree. -- nm - loosilu May 24, 10:01
        
        but I think you're missing one point (spoilers) - znufrii May 24, 09:54
    - nods -- nm - tRuMaN May 24, 09:46
    - Exactly. - Nightcrawler May 24, 09:46
- I was enraged by that. Honest to jeebus I was yelling at the TV. (nm) - musubi May 24, 09:42 1
  - Ditto. - Dr.Vermin May 24, 09:50
- Made me nuts as well. -- nm - pmb May 24, 09:41
Spoilers - David May 24, 09:39 16
- This is a false choice though. I've never been marooned on a magic island. - musubi May 24, 09:41 15
  - (spoils) - Inigo May 24, 09:54 11
    - (spoils) - musubi May 24, 10:01
    - spoils. - loosilu May 24, 09:56 9
      - (spoils) - Inigo May 24, 09:57 8
        
        I can see that complaint, but really it didn't bother me. - musubi May 24, 10:06 2
        
        (spoils) - Inigo May 24, 10:09 1
        
        Actually, (spoils) - musubi May 24, 10:12
        
        that didn't bother me so much - loosilu May 24, 10:00 3
        
        The other explanation could be (spoils) - Inigo May 24, 10:05 2
        
        what is - loosilu May 24, 10:10 1
        
        People that hate Jack call his tears JEARS. -- nm - Inigo May 24, 10:12
        
        I can totally see that objection. - Mel Profit May 24, 09:58
  - Spoilers - David May 24, 09:42 2
    - I can answer it, but it means nothing. I'll say "no", if makes you feel better, but it still means nothing. - musubi May 24, 09:44
    - my answer... - Mel Profit May 24, 09:43

Post a message top

David, I have much less problem with (spoilers)

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.