ST Alpha - "spoiler" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 163

In response to "Hmm, I had no problem with it." by Nightcrawler

spoiler

Posted by znufrii May 24 '10, 09:44

agreed. I read a very compelling apologia for it as well, the main thrust of it being that Jin would have had to live with the guilt of leaving Sun the rest of his life, with his daughter being a daily reminder of that. Probably not the best environment for her to grow up in...

Show Spoilers

Responses:

I don't buy that. This is supposed to be (spoils) - musubi May 24, 09:48 11
- it's an arguable point. - znufrii May 24, 09:53 10
  - Look at their story arcs, it's all about (spoil) - musubi May 24, 09:57 8
    - Yeah, they wrote that for the romantic ideal instead of emotional reality. (spoils) - Inigo May 24, 10:02 6
      - yes he was. -- nm - loosilu May 24, 10:03
      - yes to your IM. (spoilers) - znufrii May 24, 10:02 4
        
        oh, that was another thing that bugged me - Reagen May 24, 10:05 3
        
        Yeah, especially since he was older in the normal timeline. (spoils) - Inigo May 24, 10:11 2
        
        I think they really wanted to give us what you said in your IM, - loosilu May 24, 10:13
        
        (spoilers) - znufrii May 24, 10:13
    - I totally agree. -- nm - loosilu May 24, 10:01
  - but I think you're missing one point (spoilers) - znufrii May 24, 09:54
nods -- nm - tRuMaN May 24, 09:46
Exactly. - Nightcrawler May 24, 09:46

Post a message top

spoiler

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.