ST Alpha - "That college humor Lost video from B2 is pretty great. -- nm" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Login
Create Account

Search Dr. S. Talk
TT/ST Wiki
How Well Do You Know ...

RSS Feed

Hosting by DigitalOcean

Support ST on Ko-Fi

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 153

That college humor Lost video from B2 is pretty great. -- nm

Posted by Inigo (aka Inigo) May 25 '10, 17:24

(No message)

Responses:

This is probably the biggest unanswered question. -- (link) - the wrong element, bad guy May 25, 17:34 [youtube]
Was Mr. Eko one of the candidates? That is a *great* point. -- nm - David May 25, 17:33 13
- no mystery. he just wanted way too much money to appear in the final episode -- nm - wheezy May 25, 18:18 2
  - they could have used a cardboard cutout or something. geez. -- nm - Beryllium May 25, 18:40
  - Beaker already said that and it's not the point of the question. - David May 25, 18:19
- Wasn't everyone? -- nm - nubby May 25, 17:43
- spoils? - Beaker May 25, 17:42 2
  - I realize this but is he on the wall or the lighthouse thing? -- nm - David May 25, 17:43 1
    - Lostpedia thinks he wasn't. I guess somebody was paying attention that day. -- nm - David May 25, 17:46
- According to waht Loosi posted from the alleged Bad Robot writer he might have been. -- nm - the liioulu with the same stuff as earlier May 25, 17:41 2
  - actually Remlik posted in on a BB. -- nm - loosilu May 25, 17:43 1
    - Ahh, and you posted it on Facebook. That's why I've mixed it up. -- nm - the liioulu with the same stuff as earlier May 25, 17:48
- Not if he was killable by Smokey. nm - Dignan May 25, 17:37 1
  - I mean, they're trapped either way since he wasn't killed the first time but was the second but that would be glaring. -- nm - David May 25, 17:42
- I had to take a break in the middle of this to process a bit. -- nm - David May 25, 17:36
All that matters is that we enjoyed being fucked around for six years. nm - Dignan May 25, 17:26 36
- Once they made what was supposed to be a one off character (Ben) one of the main players, I new there was no far reaching plan. - Inigo May 25, 17:33 4
  - who cares? he was worth changing the plot. -- nm - loosilu May 25, 17:41
  - thankfully as he was the best of the best on the show. -- nm - Beaker May 25, 17:37
  - I assumed that (spoil?) - Dignan May 25, 17:36
  - Errr, they knew they could do whatever... -- nm - Inigo May 25, 17:34
- if you didn't enjoy the journey, why would you have stuck with it? -- nm - loosilu May 25, 17:30 29
  - typical codependents in an abusive relationship -- nm - zdroid May 25, 17:47 14
    - laughing. This is surprisingly accurate for dignan, I think. -- nm - loosilu May 25, 17:48 13
      - so when did leaving dozens of storylines dangle and deadends become acceptable? before sopranos certainly -- nm - zdroid May 25, 17:54 12
        
        When the characters became lovable enough to negate the plot. nm - Dignan May 25, 17:56 11
        
        You and I are on the same page here. The ending isn't supported by quite a bit of what they introduced - TWuG May 25, 18:00 2
        
        Kim and I were just talking about this. - David May 25, 18:24 1
        
        I think a zen approach is needed for the ending to work. It's probably the most appropriate approach - TWuG May 25, 18:33
        
        I don't usually say this, but you are so wrong. -- nm - loosilu May 25, 17:57 7
        
        Nonsense. "Don't fuck your audience" should be the golden rule of television writing. - Dignan May 25, 18:00 5
        
        I enjoyed trying to figure out what was important and what wasn't. - loosilu May 25, 18:07 4
        
        Stop saying "spoon fed." - Dignan May 25, 18:17 1
        
        I wouldn't say arbitrary. sometimes a dead end was a clear dead end. -- nm - loosilu May 25, 18:31
        
        On what basis were you able to figure that out? -- nm - mara May 25, 18:16 1
        
        hit and miss. -- nm - loosilu May 25, 18:30
        
        I say it a lot. (nm) - David May 25, 17:58
  - I was working on the (reasonable) assumption that I wasn't being fucked with. nm - Dignan May 25, 17:34 12
    - I wonder if the writers considered the idea that they could make the ending about love and heaven *and* still tie up loose ends. -- nm - Inigo May 25, 17:44 1
      - You're an idiot to expect this much from a TV show. I mean, come on. nm - Dignan May 25, 17:48
    - It's a TV show. Why would that be a reasonable assumption? -- nm - Roger More May 25, 17:42 8
      - "You're dumb for expecting it to be narratively consistent and logical" is an unacceptable criticism. nm - Dignan May 25, 17:46 6
        
        I thought it became clear after a couple of seasons that there were far too many twists, inconsistencies, and dead ends for them to ever be able - loosilu May 25, 17:47 5
        
        I think a room full of gifted writers could have answered 90% of those loose ends within the framework they were dealing with. nm - Dignan May 25, 17:49 4
        
        I truly don't mind the loose ends. It made things fun. -- nm - loosilu May 25, 17:53
        
        It would have been nice if they'd tried more. Ah well. -- nm - David May 25, 17:51
        
        so you are mad they didn't gift wrap everything with a bow? seriously? -- nm - Beaker May 25, 17:50 1
        
        Everything, no. A huge chunk of those glaring ommissions, *of course.* nm - Dignan May 25, 17:54
      - cause no other show ever has done it before! none ever!!! -- nm - Beaker May 25, 17:43
    - You're so gullible. -- nm - mara May 25, 17:40
  - word -- nm - Beaker May 25, 17:34
- Daaaaaamn straight. -- nm - Sting May 25, 17:27
[deleted]

Post a message top

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.