ST Alpha - "The guy who buys a ticket probably owns a fielding glove. What do I win? (nm)" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Login
Create Account

Search Dr. S. Talk
TT/ST Wiki
How Well Do You Know ...

RSS Feed

Hosting by DigitalOcean

Support ST on Ko-Fi

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 167

In response to "What's the difference between someone who buys a ticket to the Hall of Fame and Edgar Martinez?" by David

The guy who buys a ticket probably owns a fielding glove. What do I win? (nm)

Posted by musubi Oct 16 '08, 11:09

.

Responses:

the DH has been part of baseball for 35 years, deal with it -- nm - crash davis Oct 16, 11:12 11
- DH's better be absolutely dominant to deserve HOF status, deal with *that*. (nm) - musubi Oct 16, 11:18 7
  - dominant? like so dominant as to be considered the best there was at the position and have MLB rename a trophy after them? -- nm - crash davis Oct 16, 11:22 6
    - No, like better than all the other hitters who have played at real positions. - musubi Oct 16, 11:25 5
      - so you want to throw the glove guys out of the Hall? -- nm - crash davis Oct 16, 11:28 4
        
        Of course not (well, not all of them). Hitting prowess is regarded in the context of the primary position played. - musubi Oct 16, 11:35 3
        
        even using your contextual argument, I ask again, do you want Ozzie Smith thrown out of the Hall of Fame? -- nm - crash davis Oct 16, 11:38 2
        
        The guy whom many regarded as the best defensive player to ever play the game? Nah. - musubi Oct 16, 11:43 1
        
        Oh, I see. *Flair* is the deciding aspect. How very Office Space. -- nm - David Oct 16, 11:45
- Players don't come up through the minors developing thei DH skills. They play the position because either they can't field anymore or... - Inigo Oct 16, 11:16 2
  - ahem -- nm - Big Pappi Oct 16, 11:18 1
    - Even he started as a first baseman. -- nm - Inigo Oct 16, 11:21

Post a message top

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.