ST Alpha - "AL 34th Man Vote" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 151

In response to "AL reserves" by nubby

AL 34th Man Vote

Posted by nubby Jul 4 '10, 09:52

Konerko
Swisher
D. Young
M. Young
Youkilis

Responses:

NL 34th Man Vote - nubby Jul 4, 09:53 23
- And did they really fubar the Strasburg thing in it's entirety? - Will Hunting Jul 4, 10:01 21
  - [deleted]
  - well that and the fact he doesn't deserve to be an All-Star -- nm - CQ Jul 4, 10:15 15
    - when you force a player from every team... you already compromised deserving it -- nm - stewie Jul 4, 10:37
    - Put him on the last guy in vote and see what the fans think. -- nm - Will Hunting Jul 4, 10:17 13
      - Cargo's having a better rookie season (better than Heyward too, btw) -- nm - flavorize Jul 4, 10:19 1
        
        [deleted]
      - yeah, he'd be in based on ESPN hype and crap no doubt. Still, you can't add a guy to an all-star team because of potential. -- nm - CQ Jul 4, 10:19 10
        
        Yeah, it wasn't ESPN hype. - Will Hunting Jul 4, 10:21 9
        
        and if he keeps it up for the rest of the year and next year, then he can be your precious little all-star and you can throw a party -- nm - CQ Jul 4, 10:24 7
        
        Did he kill your dog or something? - Will Hunting Jul 4, 10:26 6
        
        I think he's fantastic, but his body of work, to me, is not enough to justify an all-star appearance. -- nm - CQ Jul 4, 10:29 5
        
        110% concur -- nm - TFox Jul 4, 11:41
        
        I agree with you completely. Not this year, not with the small sample size we have right now. -- nm - Krusty Jul 4, 10:56
        
        That's why you let the fans decide. - Will Hunting Jul 4, 10:32 2
        
        but this time it matters! -- nm - CQ Jul 4, 10:33 1
        
        If the fans get to vote for the teams and every team has to be represented then the game shouldn't count for anything. - Krusty Jul 4, 10:59
        
        He does have an all-star arm. But only playing 1/3 of the 1st half, hard to justify. Blame the Nats, for not calling him up sooner - flavorize Jul 4, 10:24
  - I'm not sure. He's only played 4 out of the 13 weeks, with only 6 starts and a 2-2 record. I guess it comes down to "best players" vs "best 1st half" -- nm - flavorize Jul 4, 10:11
  - It was the first question Manuel was asked and he was prickly about it. -- nm - David Jul 4, 10:03
  - Manuel said - nubby Jul 4, 10:02 1
    - What a candy-ass thing to attempt to justify it. - Will Hunting Jul 4, 10:04
- CARGO! -- nm - flavorize Jul 4, 09:58

Post a message top

AL 34th Man Vote

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.