ST Alpha - "Arhur Rhosde over Billy Wagner is pretty nonsensical too. " (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 153

In response to "Omar Infante over Ryan Zimmerman is the most ridiculous All-star choice I think i've ever seen." by musubi

Arhur Rhosde over Billy Wagner is pretty nonsensical too.

Posted by musubi Jul 4 '10, 13:17

Jeebus the rosters are asinine. *this is the nonsense* that means Strasburg can't be an allstar?

Responses:

Arthur Rhodes went 98% of the season to date without giving up a run or something. -- nm - Will Hunting Jul 4, 13:46 6
- His ERA until June 26th was 0.28. He was as lights out as an reliever at any point you'll likely ever find. -- nm - Will Hunting Jul 4, 13:48 5
  - On June 26th Luke Gregerson had a 1.64 ERA, 0.53 (!) WHIP, 49 K: 4(!) BB in more innings than Rhodes. - musubi Jul 4, 13:53 4
    - Rhodes ERA was 0.28.....the entire goal is not to give up runs. - Will Hunting Jul 4, 13:57 3
      - You know that relievers pitch so few innings that ERA is a very rough measure. The difference between Gregerson's ERA and Rhodes is 4 total runs. - musubi Jul 4, 14:29 2
        
        Rhodes is *best-ever* territory. Gregerson is once a year territory. - Will Hunting Jul 4, 14:56 1
        
        He's not Infante-level bad selection, but there are other, better choices. (nm) - musubi Jul 4, 15:15
Rhodes has been lights out all season and his numbers are very good. Wagner is also having a good season but I don't think it's a big mistake. -- nm - Krusty Jul 4, 13:22 13
- Rhodes has been a very good reliever. Wags is an elite pitcher, it's not even close. - musubi Jul 4, 13:26 12
  - I agree that Wagner deserves to go but I don't think it's nonsense to choose Rhodes. *shrug* -- nm - Krusty Jul 4, 13:31 11
    - The other thing, if you're gonna select a non-closing reliever, it makes no sense to not choose Luke Gregerson. (nm) - musubi Jul 4, 13:40 10
      - Rhodes era until last week was 0.28. He'd given up 1 run all season. - Will Hunting Jul 4, 13:54 8
        
        No. Even if he hadn't allow a run all year it's not historic. He's pitched 33 innings. That's not historic at all. - musubi Jul 4, 14:34 7
        
        Actually, it is. 33 straight appearances without a run allowed tied the record. - Will Hunting Jul 4, 14:59 6
        
        Again 33 innings. It's absolutely a great accomplishment, and he's been wonderful. But Gregerson by almost every significant measure has been better - musubi Jul 4, 15:13 5
        
        Becuase the entire goal of a reliever is not to let the other guys score. - Will Hunting Jul 4, 15:20 4
        
        Gregerson right now has the lowest WHIP a reliever (min 40 innings) has EVER put up. Better than Eck in 89 and 90. - musubi Jul 4, 15:27 3
        
        Other than letting guys score which again, Rhodes was historic as recently as last Tuesday. - Will Hunting Jul 4, 15:30 1
        
        Rhodes is good. To be fair, yes, he's deserving of an AS nod. But more than Wagner or Gregerson? - musubi Jul 4, 15:32
        
        That's including his bad innings, not just a lucky streak. (nm) - musubi Jul 4, 15:29
      - I'm not joking, I have no clue who he is. :-) He might be having a great year but I've never heard of him. -- nm - Krusty Jul 4, 13:46
Agreed on both. -- nm - nubby Jul 4, 13:19

Post a message top

Arhur Rhosde over Billy Wagner is pretty nonsensical too.

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.