Log In
Create Account
SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ
Login
Create Account
Search
Dr. S. Talk
TT/ST Wiki
How Well Do You Know ...
RSS Feed
Hosting by DigitalOcean
Support ST on Ko-Fi
Links Only
50 Results
100 Results
250 Results
500 Results
1000 Results
5000 Results
2 Weeks
2 Months
6 Months
1 Year
2 Years
5 Years
All Time
Live
Down to Post
Backboards:
Live
________________
1: Dec 3, 14:19
2: Dec 3, 11:17
3: Dec 3, 07:33
4: Dec 2, 17:22
5: Dec 2, 11:48
6: Dec 2, 08:21
7: Dec 1, 17:33
8: Dec 1, 11:23
9: Nov 30, 15:54
10: Nov 30, 09:41
11: Nov 29, 16:44
12: Nov 29, 08:01
13: Nov 28, 16:19
14: Nov 28, 09:42
15: Nov 27, 18:07
16: Nov 27, 12:04
17: Nov 27, 08:26
18: Nov 26, 18:06
19: Nov 26, 12:05
20: Nov 26, 08:29
Posts: 154
In response to
"
The best website for data, true. The best for analysis...eh, it's good, but not he best.
"
by
musubi
The good news for Edgar is that as small minded people such as yourself get overwhelmed by stats gurus who appreciate Edgar's greatness, he'll get in.
Posted by
David (aka David)
Sep 14 '10, 11:33
So, he'll be a veteran's committee selection.
Responses:
Stat gurus are just as split on Edgars value. It has nothing to do with Stats vs non-stats. it's just how big a HOF you believe there should be.
-
musubi
Sep 14, 11:40
1
For the second time today, I'll say that if there are more than 100 hitters in the Hall, one of the best 100 hitters should be in.
-
David
Sep 14, 11:44
I just do not think he is/ was good enough.
-
groiny
Sep 14, 11:36
Post a message
top
Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.