ST Alpha - "I must have missed something re: Black Swan. I thought it was just okay." (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 152

I must have missed something re: Black Swan. I thought it was just okay.

Posted by kelly (aka kelly) Dec 20 '10, 14:07

Natalie Portman was amazing, but I wasn't all that impressed with the rest of it.

My coworker saw it this weekend and he LOVED it, so this now means that every person I know who has seen it has loved it - except for me.

Responses:

It's like you're Elaine and everybody's raving about The English Patient. - Trish Dec 20, 14:13 6
- except the english patient is a fine film -- nm - pixmas Dec 20, 14:14 5
  - At the risk of agreeing with pixie, yes. -- nm - Reagen Dec 20, 14:24
  - I've never seen that -- nm - JenBro Dec 20, 14:18 1
    - *adds it to your list* -- nm - pixmas Dec 20, 14:21
  - don't you mean it is on fine film stock, but the movie itself sucked? -- nm - peglegpete Dec 20, 14:15
  - There's a fine line between love and nausea. -- nm - Max Dec 20, 14:14
It's effective, but I after seeing it I didn't think it was a story that needed to be told. - Max Dec 20, 14:13 1
- [deleted]
Dawson and I agree with what you think I believe. I gave it a B (upped b/c Portman was so great) -- nm - MDH Dec 20, 14:09 2
- I'd probably give it a C+. -- nm - kelly Dec 20, 14:11
- Yeah, pretty much. And I was at least entertained for its duration. Definitely not a boring film. -- nm - con_carne wants it so bad Dec 20, 14:10
i have no desire to see it at all -- nm - pixmas Dec 20, 14:09
I did not love it - I thought it was good but not great. - definitely different -- nm - Epiphany Dec 20, 14:09
B- -- nm - con_carne wants it so bad Dec 20, 14:08

Post a message top

I must have missed something re: Black Swan. I thought it was just okay.

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.