ST Alpha - "when the pie is good? hmm? ST Pie Poll: What was the worst pie you ever had?" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 156

when the pie is good? hmm? ST Pie Poll: What was the worst pie you ever had?

Posted by Beryllium (aka grayman) Feb 23 '11, 13:09

I had a bad experience with Strawberry Rhubarb. That's all I can think of, really.

Responses:

I could do without strawberry rhubarb, I guess. I dunno... -- nm - con_carne Feb 23, 13:19
Ooh, I had some not very good sheppard's pie. - musubi Feb 23, 13:18 1
- "You made half an English Trifle and...half a shepherd's pie!" -- nm - oblique Feb 23, 13:19
I dislike peach pie is about it. -- nm - decline Feb 23, 13:15 2
- it is kind of gross, isn't it? I know it's not rational, but I swear it tastes fuzzy. -- nm - amanda jones Feb 23, 13:17 1
  - next time ask sash to brazilian her peaches before baking. -- nm - Max Feb 23, 13:18
i just in general hate the taste of pumpkin pie so, that. -- nm - Diva Feb 23, 13:14 1
- i won't try and change your mind - moles Feb 23, 13:16
I dislike most lunch place pies, they seem to be just barely cooked, the crust is still doughy and the filling is corn starchy goo -- nm - zeitgeist Feb 23, 13:14
Pies with nuts in them. Like Pecan. Blech -- nm - oblique Feb 23, 13:13 4
- dumb. ass. -- nm - TFox Feb 23, 13:16 2
  - I will take your word for it that "Ass Pie" is disgusting -- nm - amoxy Feb 23, 13:18
  - Maybe you like having nuts in your mouth but I don't -- nm - oblique Feb 23, 13:17
- Ooh this past X-mas, I had a Sweet Potato-Pecan Pie that was *heavenly*. (nm) - musubi Feb 23, 13:15
This is gonna devolve into Pie vs Cake again, I just know it. (nm) - musubi Feb 23, 13:12
my sister always makes pie too complex. like it has to be blueberry streusel cream cheese pie, not just plain blueberry. - amanda jones Feb 23, 13:12 21
- wtf ann? -- nm - moles Feb 23, 13:12 20
  - I know! it makes me weepy, almsot. JUST PIE. there are two ingredients in pie: blueberry and pie or cherry and pie. she's like insane. - amanda jones Feb 23, 13:13 19
    - there can be two other ingredients, like strawberry and rhubarb. -- nm - Max Feb 23, 13:14 15
      - I don't get rhubarb pie. why would you make a pie out of pink celery? -- nm - loosilu Feb 23, 13:18 13
        
        because it grows well in some parts of the country and there's not much else you can do with it -- nm - zeitgeist Feb 23, 13:28 1
        
        use the dirt to grow something else? -- nm - loosilu Feb 23, 13:33
        
        Rhubarb's kind of irrational -- it takes so much sugar to offset the sourness -- but with the sugar, it's damn good. -- nm - mara Feb 23, 13:19 8
        
        I have never had rhubarb pie, but I really want to try it. (nm) - musubi Feb 23, 13:21 6
        
        I'll make it for you. I'll even use the entire plant. -- nm - Max Feb 23, 13:21 5
        
        Is this like how Native Americans use the entire buffalo? (nm) - musubi Feb 23, 13:23 1
        
        oh yeah. it'll give you a permanent vision quest. -- nm - Max Feb 23, 13:24
        
        my mom used to make this rhubarb cobbler thing when i was a kid. i should get that recipe. -- nm - Andie Feb 23, 13:22 2
        
        My mom made rhubard upside-down cake. So good. -- nm - mara Feb 23, 13:35
        
        and then give it to me. *darth vader force pose* -- nm - Max Feb 23, 13:24
        
        this -- nm - oblique Feb 23, 13:20
        
        I think it's a peasant thing. Filler because strawberries aren't cheap. -- nm - Beryllium Feb 23, 13:19 1
        
        I wonder if the reason I like strawberry pie so much is because it makes me feel rich. -- nm - amanda jones Feb 23, 13:20
      - agree with concept, disagree with example. :) -- nm - Beryllium Feb 23, 13:15
    - she needs piehab -- nm - moles Feb 23, 13:14
    - except in the case of pie and lemon and meringue ... -- nm - Beryllium Feb 23, 13:14 1
      - totally. or *every now and again* chocolate and peanut butter and pie. (not often though. you'll get fatter.) -- nm - amanda jones Feb 23, 13:14
OMG, I once had squash pie that was evil incarnate. - Amy Feb 23, 13:11
you have pie rankings? - loosilu Feb 23, 13:11 3
- Pie or Not Pie. -- nm - Beryllium Feb 23, 13:12 2
  - if I have to pick one, I guess I've had some bad quiche. -- nm - loosilu Feb 23, 13:15 1
    - I'll allow it. -- nm - Beryllium Feb 23, 13:16
i just can't like cherry pie. i try, i don't. -- nm - Andie Feb 23, 13:10 2
- Jesus, that's probably my favorite fruit pie -- nm - con_carne Feb 23, 13:12
- have you had a good homemade one, without the syrupy cherry gunk from a can? - moles Feb 23, 13:12
Too easy. - con_carne Feb 23, 13:10
i can't think of one off the top of my head. i guess some apples have been not quite done but so what -- nm - moles Feb 23, 13:10
Mince Meat - Blech -- nm - amoxy Feb 23, 13:10

Post a message top

when the pie is good? hmm? ST Pie Poll: What was the worst pie you ever had?

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.