ST Alpha - "I'm really not liking Frank Miller as a director." (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 154

In response to "So The Spirit... um, I guess I don't much like Frank Miller's style? Or maybe I was expecting cheese but not THAT much cheese? Anyway, hate it. -- nm" by Qale

I'm really not liking Frank Miller as a director.

Posted by ReluctantCynic (aka ReluctantCynic) Dec 25 '08, 20:41

The parts of Sin City that Robert Rodriguez credited miller as having the most influence over were the weakest, lamest parts of the movie. And everything I've read about The Spirit is just awful.

Responses:

I didn't like Sin City -- felt it was a full-on assault that lacked a fun flair to the noir. I liked 300, but there isn't much substance to that film - Qale Dec 25, 20:45 5
- Other than the visuals, Sin City was a pointless mess. -- nm - Cuzzin Toddnog Dec 25, 20:52
- Miller is a fantastic writer of comics (and not a bad artist), but I think his ego has gotten the best of him. - ReluctantCynic Dec 25, 20:51 3
  - was. you must have never read the second Darknight miniseries -- nm - black peter Dec 25, 20:56 1
    - Yeah ... that wasn't his best work at all. Average at best. -- nm - ReluctantCynic Dec 25, 21:01
  - It's obvious where his talents lie (comics). I should have known better when the word Lionsgate appeared on screen I was in for a doozy. -- nm - Qale Dec 25, 20:54

Post a message top

I'm really not liking Frank Miller as a director.

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.