ST Alpha - "American Idol thoughts" (Reading a Post)

SlickerTalk
Search Archives
The Leaderboard
The FAQ

Down to Post

Backboards:

Posts: 158

American Idol thoughts

Posted by con_Blarney (aka con_carne) Mar 17 '11, 10:34

I think Naima is going home. I don't think she's that good, and she just sings off pitch too much.

"Smells Like Teen Spirit" Casey: Meh, it was okay. JLo was right, he screamed that song a lot, as if that was the only thing to be done during the performance. I don't think that's very daring, just stupid.

Scotty is still me favorite to win it all, but Jacob is very good. Even though neither of these guys sing music genres that I like a lot. James and Casey are who I want to see more of. James messed up. He turned "I'll Be There For You" into a happy sing along, when that is not what the song is about. It is about pain and longing and asking for redemption. Sheesh.

"Don't get all poppy on me!" and "I love when you show your ethnic what-it-isness" were my two favorite moments of the night, both said by Steven Tyler. :)

Responses:

I don't really know who's who, but I have noticed that I find I am just not at all in sync with the judges anymore. I used to find that I was - pmb Mar 17, 10:47
I hate how for the last few seasons they took out the factor of them having to remember the lyrics. - zork Mar 17, 10:38 1
- Kaoroke Idol. -- nm - Beaker Mar 17, 10:39
speaking of shows that have run their course... -- nm - amanda "training day" jones Mar 17, 10:35 6
- yes, i really want this show to end, or at least have something else capture the imagination of our female office workers - ceregon Mar 17, 10:42 3
  - I love this. So, if they asked you who you like, what would you say? :) -- nm - con_Blarney Mar 17, 10:47 2
    - I'd say I liked the screecher, thought the fuzzy guy had an off night and like the girl that sings the power ballads -- nm - ceregon Mar 17, 10:50 1
      - Pia? - con_Blarney Mar 17, 10:53
- It's all good. Haters gon' hate. -- nm - con_Blarney Mar 17, 10:39
- to some extent, yes, but the talent selection this time was better without Simon and Paula. -- nm - zork Mar 17, 10:39

Post a message top

American Idol thoughts

Replies are disabled on threads older than 7 days.